Zen is not a religion. This is a position I have
continuously maintained. To say that Zen is not a religion is to say that
the Buddha-Way [butsudo] is not a religion. However, religious concepts invariably
are entwined with words such as Zen or the Buddha-Way. Most people have no
problem with the statement that Zen is not a religion, but I think that there
are many who have some trouble with the statement that the Buddha-Way is not a
religion. Why is Zen not a religion? Why is the Buddha-Way not a religion? In
clarifying these questions at the same time I would like to consider the
question of why religious concepts are entwined with the terms Zen and
Buddha-Way.
To introduce this discussion we must begin from
the question of what is a religion. But it is said that the definitions
of religion number as many as there are experts in that field. Here, for my purposes,
I will use the definition given in the Kojien[1] which
seems to be representative. According to the Kojien: gReligion means activities and faith in a god or some kind
of sacred being, which is differentiated from other worldly beings. And it also
refers to those related structures.h In other words fundamental to establishing
religion is to recognize a being that transcends the power of nature and of
human beings. And from that one can say that religion involves faith in that
transcendent being and activities based on that faith.
But then what is Zen? As I am always saying, Zen is experientially finding onefs true self and
the effort to personalize that true self which was found. Put very simply, Zen
is the pursuit and clarification of onefs true self. It is no exaggeration to
say that that is Zen in its entirety. The object of Zen is, in the final
analysis, the self and nothing else except the self. It should be clear then
that religion, which begins from recognition of a transcendent being that
transcends the self, and Zen are totally different entities.
; But what of the Buddha-Way? As I wrote in the previous issue, Buddha and the Buddha-Way are
ways of naming the true self which has been discovered. The true self that has
been found is really one with all that is. The self and the whole universe are
originally one being. In order to differentiate this true self that has been
found from the one before, the words Buddha and Buddha-Way are used. By all
means I want each of you not to forget that Buddha is another name for you
yourself.
If one wants to go so far as to distinguish Buddha and Buddha-Way, one might say that Buddha
refers to the true self and Buddha-Way refers to the functions of that true
self. Nevertheless, each of these expressions is nothing other than a
description of the true self. ""
But why is it that the terms "Zen,"
"Buddha," "Buddha-Way" are associated in common thinking
with religion or a part of religion? I think it is because the true self
which has been found, the real self, is so far separated from the illusory
self which had been seen as the self up to then. The fact that the whole
universe, all that is, and the self are exactly one and the same, is something
too far removed from what one had thought about the self up to then. For,
those who have not found the true self -- that is the greater part of all
humanity -- cannot conceive of this experience in any other way than that
of the self as some kind of completely transcendent being. And thus this
would enter the realm of religion.
And the main reason that the Buddha-Way is being
confused with religion is that those who should be responsible for disseminating
the true Buddha-Way -- that is monks of the temples and the great majority
of those in charge of temples -- look upon Buddha as a transcendent being
and preach to others to have faith in the Buddha.
In conclusion, what separates those who consider Zen or the Buddha-Way as a religion or as
something free of religion, is the presence or absence of a clear experiential
discovery of the true self. It can be said that to be free of religion means
the switch from faith to the pursuit and discovery of the truth of existence,
and the process in which Zen and natural science ceaselessly come closer and
closer. In that sense the mission of the SANBÔZEN is the de-religionizing
of Zen.
The words of Kôun Roshi express this perfectly. gChristians who do Zazen can become better
Christians. Muslims can become better Muslims.h
|